Cuffed Beanie Etsy Profit Calculator

Etsy takes three separate bites out of every Cuffed Beanie sale — a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing — all charged on your item price plus shipping. Right now Printful fulfills the Cuffed Beanie for $13.05 + $4.99 shipping, and Printify from $15.26 + $4.69; most sellers list it between $18.99 and $24.99.

At a $21.99 price with free shipping and Printful fulfillment, that's $2.54 in Etsy fees, leaving $1.41 profit per sale — a 6.4% margin, or roughly 709 sales to clear $1,000 in profit. For the Cuffed Beanie, Printful is the more profitable fulfiller on Etsy — about $1.91 more per sale at $21.99 (all-in cost $18.04 on Printful vs $19.95 on Printify). Breakeven — the price where profit hits $0 — is $20.43 on Printful; sell below that and you're paying to make the sale.

One cost this calculator leaves out: Etsy Offsite Ads can add 12–15% on top, but only when a sale comes through one of those ads — so your real average fee sits a little above the numbers here.